Christmas. That great time of year characterized by family gatherings, excellent food, beautiful decorations, and gifting. As far as i can tell we give gifts at Christmas to honor and remember God’s gift of Christ to us. Awesome! The problem comes when you take into account the fact that it’s people who are trying to give the gifts.
Fact: people in general aren’t particularly good at gifting.
In my selfishness i’m way more likely to know what i want or could use than what might make good gifts for my friends and relatives. Even if i do think of something good, what are the chances that it conforms to my rather restricted budget? Turns out the difficulties i run into with gifting are a bit on the common side and they’ve resulted in two main problems:
1. Buying bad gifts
How many Christmases have you had? And what percentage of the gifts you’ve received have gone unused, wasted, or stored away in some attic until the next Ebay purge? It’s a sad truth that a lot of times people buy stuff that we don’t really want and can’t or won’t use. All this waste is bad economics 101. It’s also bad for the spirit, sowing discontent in the recipient and hurt feelings in the giver.
2. Asking for a list
Generally employed by parents and grandparents on children, this seemingly workable solution asks for all sorts of trouble. You, the loving parent, want to make your child happy and get him something he will love. You’re afraid of problem #1, especially seeing as the child probably isn’t mature enough to be understanding and accept bad gifts with thankfulness, so you just come right out and ask him what he wants. The child then sits there and thinks of all the things he doesn’t have that he would like to. Discontent much? Then on Christmas morning, since he told you what he wanted, he’s expecting some assortment of those items to be under the tree. If the new Legos pirate ship was at the top of his list, there’s a pretty good chance there’s a new Legos pirate ship wrapped in pretty paper for him. You’ve just turned “God has blessed me, so i will bless others with voluntary giving” into an obligatory business transaction. You also taught your kid entitlement.
So what do i do with all of this? One half of me wants to rebel, to refuse to put up with the degradation of a holiday thatshould be awesome, that should be full of thanksgiving and general goodwill. I want to refuse to make a Christmas list, to tell people to just give cash to a charity instead (hmm that’s actually kind of a good idea). I mean it’s not like i actually need any more stuff in my life.
But the other half of me is more Ferengi-minded (read selfish). It thinks, “Hey these people want to spend money on me. It will make them happy to buy me stuff and they’re not likely to be sold on the charity idea, so i might as well get something good out of the whole deal.” This thought means that i go ahead and make the list; i get stuff that i probably would have bought eventually anyway, and the whole holiday turns into more of a filled order than an exercise in generosity and love.